Friday, January 10, 2014

Review: Bose Soundlink Wireless Music System - oldtimer redux!

Bose has the habit of very long life-cycles for their products. I have no idea how long their Waveradio has already been on the market without much changes in design or acoustics (not to mention their nearly 50 year old 910 speakers).
The same is true for their Bose Sounddock, which now is revived within the 3rd vesion, but didn't change much from the very first version that came out 10 years ago.

The core of the Bose Sounddock portable (now discontiuned) even found its way into several different products. One of them being the Soundlink Air, another one the current Soundtouch 20 (but this time without the option of an additional battery). But the first one to use the same design was the Bose Soundlink Wireless System brought to the market in 2009 and meanwhile discontinued as well. The Bose Soundlink Wireless System was marketed as a wireless home system, where you could stream music wirelessly from your computer to the speaker through a special included USB-dongle. The Soundlink Wireless System was quite overpriced at the beginning costing around 550$.
What hardly anyone knows is that the Soundlink Wireless System was a simple Bluetooth speaker. There is no need for the dongle, the speaker can easily pair with any A2DP enabled smartphone.

When someone asked me about a speaker more powerful than the TDK A33 or the Bose Soundlink II, but without the bulk of a boombox like the Altec Lansing Mix or Klipsch KMC-3 there is hardly anything on the market. I had sold my Bose Sounddock Portable half a year ago, as I haven't used it anymore that often, because of the dedicated Apple-Dock and because due to heavy usage the dock got bad contact and wouldn't charge my Iphone anymore, but also because the Soundlink Mini was enough for my needs most of the time, as I didn't need the power or volume of the larger Bose speakers. Funnily the Mini even managed to sound more convincing than the bigger ones up to normal room listening levels.
Either the speakers are really small like the Soundlink Mini, JBL Charge, UE Boom etc, or book-sized like the Soundlink II, the Loewe speaker2go, TDK A33. But then there is a big gap until the really big ghettoblasters jump in with nothing inbetween.
I only found the new IK Multimedia iLoud (review will be coming soon), which is indeed a nice speaker not that much larger than the Bose Soundlink II but with considerably more power (they claim 40 Watts) and volume.

But here I  would like to present an interesting alternative, that I found at Ebay. There were many used Soundlinks Wireless Music Systems for about 150-200€. Quite a bargain and much cheaper than a new iLoud for example! From my own experience Bose speakers hardly ever brake and even a used Soundlink Wireless System should do its job for the next 5-10 years if handled with care.
I got one for 199€, 3 months old with an original invoice from a store, which probably was sold during a stock clearance.

Of course I could also have bought the new Soundlink Air, but in my opinion Airplay is not so well suited for portable use. Although the Soundlink Air can be brought into some kind of direct-play mode where it would stream music directly from an Iphone without the need of an additional network, this isn't very stable and doesn't work every time. Also streaming through Airplay (or Wifi) uses much more battery than streaming through Bluetooth. Of course you can stream losslessly through Airplay, but normally in case of the Bose Soundlink Air or Soundlink Wireless System, you shouldn't be able to hear any difference between Airplay and Bluetooth, it is not the most detailed speaker.

The Soundlink Wireless Music System has the advantage of exchangeable batteries over many comparable speaker systems. A spare battery usually goes for about 70-80$, and can be exchanged within some seconds by just turning a big screw with a coin or fingernail. At highest levels the Soundlink Wireless Music System should play about 3 hours according to Bose. I had it playing at lower levels like 70%, which is already pretty loud, but the sound doesn't suffer yet because of overly strong DSP processing, and it played for more than 4 hours. At comfortable room listening levels you should be getting more than 8 hours out of one single charge. I even squeezed out more than 12 hours out of my old Sounddock Portable, I haven't tested if I manage the same with the Soundlink Wireless Music System. I am not sure if Bluetooth drains more battery than charging an Ipod, as the Sounddock Portable was charging docked devices also when running from battery.
A full charge will take about 5-6 hours. The power supply is rather huge, but it has a handy loop to wind up the wire if not in use. There is also an additional car-adapter available, so you could charge the speaker even in your boat or caravan when on the go.

In fact if you already know the Bose Sounddock Portable, you will immediately recognize the Bose Soundlink Wireless System, as both are pretty much the same, but as there is no flabby rotatable Apple dock anymore, the Soundlink Wireless System makes an overall more sturdy impression and looks cleaner designwise.

The Soundlink Wireless Music System has no controls, there are only 2 touch-buttons for changing volume at the right side. Everything else must be done through the remote. While you could use the Sounddock Portable even without remote, because it automatically turned on as soon as you touched one volume-button, this is not possible with the Soundlink Wireless Music System anymore. You have to turn it on with the remote. If you lose the remote, you won't be able use it. You could force a turn-on if you remove the battery and attach it agian, or if you attach the power cord, then the speaker automatically powers on as well. It is also powering off automatically after 20 or 30 minutes when there is no Bluetooth connection active. So far I haven't noticed an automatic power down with an active Bluetooth connection. The Soundlink Mini even turns off when connected, provided that nothing is currently playing.

When holding the wireless button on the remote for several seconds, the Soundlink Wireless Music System jumps into Bluetooth pairing mode and you can connect to it from any Bluetooth enabled device. It acts like a usual Bluetooth speaker, there is no need for the additional Bluetooth dongle (to tell the truth I haven't even tried the dongle out yet).
As the connection is based on A2DP, you can also use the remote for skipping tracks, or starting playback and pausing it again. This worked with my Iphone or Ipad, I haven't tested it with other Bluetooth enabled phones.

How is the sound? Bose like! It is not perfect though. I cannot remember if my old Sounddock Portable sounded that much different, maybe Bose tuned the Soundlink Wireless Music System a little bit, but treble sounds somewhat harsh to me, especially on-axis, while mids are more restrained making the overall sound rather dull. Especially vocals suffer a lot compared to other speakers. It is not a very natural or linear sound, but it is still very enjoyable. Bass is really powerful and well under control, until the speaker reaches 3/4 of its volume, then bass and dynamics are reduced considerably. At top volume there is also some stronger distortion, but we are talking about really loud levels already, especially for a speaker as compact as the Bose Soundlink Wireless Music System.

The Soundlink Wireless Music System sounds best at medium levels, at lower levels the sound can become too boomy as treble is muted too much then. I even prefer the sound of the much smaller Soundlink Mini at lower levels, as it sounds clearer, despite not having that much sparkle in the upper treble.
Compared to the Sonos Play:1 which seems even a bit smaller, the Bose has more power and plays louder. But the Sonos has a more natural sound with a similarly powerful bass, but less boomy. The Play:1 bass seems to even have more impact at the lowest frequencies, but it is not as pronounced in the upper region as that from the Soundlilnk Wireless Music System. The Play:1 also has a less directional sound dispersion, while the Soundlink Wireless Music System suffers quite a lot if  not listened frontally.

I prepared some comparison videos. First is an indoor comparison with the Bose Soundlink Mini at room listening volume (about 60%). The other video is an outdoor comparison where both the Soundlink Wireless Music System and the Soundlink Mini were played at their maximum volume. The Soundlink Mini is already quite powerful, but compared to its big brother it sounds rather lost especially outside.
Audio was recorded with a Zoom H2n this time, which microphone records not as bass-heavy as that from the H1.

I would claim the Soundlink Wireless Music System to be indeed better suited for outdoor listening. Outside it sounds nicely balanced due to the stronger bass, that usually gets lost pretty quickly in the open field. When cranked you can still hear it with acceptable volume from 20 meters away, and from some distance you won't even notice that much distortion even if playing at top volume. The Soundlink Wireless Music System won't be able to throw a huge beach-party, but it should have enough power for any garden grill-fiesta.
If you need something more powerful than the Soundlink II or TDK A33, but still need to keep it quite portable, grab a Bose Soundlink Wireless System if you can find one. It plays twice as loud and has an overall much more powerful and mature sound.
It is definitely worth 200$ even in used condition and I doubt it will break that soon. If the battery is already weak, you can buy a new one. There is still no real alternative at this size right now that I know, maybe the new iLoud from IK Multimedia, so stay tuned for a review and comparison of both.


  1. Aufgrund deines Reviews des Soundlink Wireless Sound Systems habe ich es mir gekauft, ich war richtig scharf auf den mini aber irgendwie war ich nicht ganz überzeugt.
    Dein Review hat mich dann zum alten Soundlink überredet.
    Ich besitze es seit rund 2h, habe es für 150€ bei eBay ersteigert.
    Da ich so bin wie ich bin, habe ich es fast sofort zerlegt um nachzuschauen was ich bekommen habe. Du meinst dass das iLoud 40 Watt hat, das Soundlink Wireless Music System aber auch. Der dort verbaute AMP bietet 2x 20W bei 8Ohm und bei 18V Eingangsspannung.
    Das hat mich auch etwas Verblüfft. Der DSP Chip kann sogar Dolby Digital und DTS dekodieren und der Kondensator für den AMP bietet ganze 10000µF. Was aber noch überraschend ist, das Gehäuse ist das selbe wie das des Sounddocks, unten ist nämlich jede menge Platz für den "Ipod Mechanismus". Das finde ich nicht so gut, und auch innen wurde viel Platz verschwendet...
    Der Akku kann kostengünstig "erneuert" werden. Es befinden sich stinknormale ziemlich schwache 18650 Zellen drin, 4 Stück insgesamt mit jeweils 1900mAh. Für etwa 20€ kann kriegt man 4 neue 2600-2800mAh Zellen, dadurch verlängert sich die Laufzeit ordentlich.
    Das Bassreflex Kanal bzw das Waveguide ist auch nicht optimal gemacht wodurch manchmal Strömungsgeräusche entstehen.
    Toller Klang für wenig Geld, mit etwas Optimierungsbedarf.
    Vielen Dank für das Review!
    Finde dein Blog Toll.
    Liebe Grüße

    1. Hey Lukas, vielen Dank für deine Nachricht. Kling total interessant. Hast du vielleicht Fotos von deinem "Teardown"? Würde sicher auch andere interessieren was drinnen ist, wir könnten die hier posten. Auch ein kleines Tutorial zum selbstgebastelten Akku wäre sicher auch für andere hilfreich.
      Kannst mich jederzeit unter o.luv at anschreiben wenn du Lust hast.
      Danke und Grüße, O.

    2. Vielen Dank schon mal für die Fotos, wie es aussieht muss man die Akkus gar nicht löten, da sie nur reingeschoben sind, oder,
      Wie hast du eigentlich den Soundlink aufgekriegt? Beim Portable konnte man das vordere Gitter wegziehen. Hab das beim Soundlink noch nicht geschafft.
      Dass sie den "Portable" einfach wieder recycelt haben hat wohl Kostengründe. Wäre der Soundlink ohne Dock niedriger würde auch der Akku nicht mehr passen, sie hätten diesen auch neu machen müssen.
      Übrigens schick mir bitte noch deine Kontaktadresse damit wir ein wenig quatschen können. Du hast einen polnischen Namen, mówisz też po polsku?

    3. Tak tez mowie hehe...
      Miejsca w Akkupack jest wystarczajaco duzo i moge sie zalozyc ze w Soundlink Air jest ta sama obudowa i ta sama bateria. Przynajmniej na zdjeciach tak wyglada.
      Ogniwa w akkupacku sa "zespawane" tzn ze trzeba je wyciac i nowe wlutowac. To juz raczej nie dla poczatkujacych, bo ciezko sie lutuje nowe ogniwa, ale mozna tez zespawane zamowic i tylko "motylki" przylutowac.
      Zeby glosnik rozebrac, trzeba ta przednia blaszke na srodku podwazyc. Mozna to zrobic paznokciem, na gorze i nadole jest zepem zfiksowana. No i delikatnie wyciagnac, moga z rogow wypasc takie gumki, sa cztery, pewnie po to zeby nie halasowala.

    4. To jednak zupełnie to samo jak w portable. Tez te same gumki były na bokach i tez na żepie się trzymało. Tylko tam ta blacha jakoś prawie sama odchodziła a tu próbowałem ale za bardzo nie chciało iść tak ze się nie szarpalem.
      Te akumulatory gdzie byś zamawial? Prez przez internet, czy gdzieś u Conrada?

    5. Könnt ihr eine Anleitung zum Zellentausch hochladen?

  2. I’ve read your posts and can relate. I recently contracted the team at Pure Audio Video to custom design an outdoor entertainment system for my house. My family and I host a lot of events in our home. We needed a system that blended into the landscape, sounded good, and could hold up in the South Florida humidity. PAV provided a great design that camouflaged with my landscape, had a limited lifetime warranty, and sounded amazing. My guests are constantly complimenting me on how clear the sound is outside. I highly recommend the Pure Audio Video team to anyone interested in an outdoor entertainment system. Visit them at .